Fractional CFO case studies: evidence before promises
Financial leadership should be judged by the problem, the actions, the timeframe, and the outcome - not a headline number without context. These four stories describe my roles as an executive, co-founder, and CFO. They are operating-company results - and they’re the same discipline I bring to every fractional client.
30+ years
as a CFO
MBA
in Marketing
CPA
Georgia State Board of Accountancy License #CPA012637 (inact)
Trusted by leaders at
Four fractional CFO case studies, told start to finish
Case study 01 · Baywalk Media to Quatrro Direct · 2005–2017
The 36-month models that took a two-founder media agency to $35M in revenue
Co-founder, CFO and COO
My co-founder led business development and product; I owned finance, operations, legal, payments, compliance, and technology.
What I led
Built 36-month models from unit economics through full financial statements, steering nearly $1M in monthly media spend across 1,000+ campaigns - every dollar measured against acquisition cost and customer lifetime value.
The models showed B2C technical support becoming the stronger opportunity. We restructured around it and combined with Quatrro to form Quatrro Direct.
Engineered the offshore delivery model: approximately 600 employees across four global centers, with six onshore in the U.S. For inbound billing customer service, we deliberately used a US call center for a better native English-speaking experience.
Set up and oversaw PCI-compliant, high-risk, multi-currency payment processing: cost below 4% of gross, refunds below 15%, chargebacks below 3%, at $60M annual capacity for five consecutive years.
~$35M
peak revenue at 20% EBITDA
~$25M
average annual revenue over a decade
1.2M
consumers served
The result: approximately $35M peak revenue at 20% EBITDA, roughly $25M average annual revenue over a decade, 1.2 million consumers served. The B2C proof of concept led Quatrro to acquire the business.
This describes Bob’s role as co-founder, CFO and COO of Baywalk Media / Quatrro Direct (2005-2017), not a Fractional CFO client engagement. Names, dates, and results are published with permission.
The takeaway: a volatile, fast-pivoting venture became a profitable, durable business - because disciplined finance and operations were in the room while the strategy was still being written. I stayed beside the same CEO from founding through exit.
Case study 02 · 800 Travel Systems · 1999–2002
A public, thin-margin travel company: from flat sales to 17% growth, then a steady hand through 9/11
CFO and Director; later board-appointed Interim CEO, COO and Chairman
A publicly traded leisure-travel company (Nasdaq: IFLY) with ~$100M in annual reservations, ~$20M net revenue, and 500 employees, selling discount air by phone and web against Expedia and Travelocity. I was referred in by the company’s auditors, Grant Thornton.
What I led
Broadened the business from air-only into cruises, hotels, tours, and a travel club through two strategic acquisitions - funded with $3.5M in working capital I raised.
Built daily KPI reporting: scheduling versus actual staffing, call-abandon rates, conversion rates, gross profit by sales agent. We ran on numbers, not hunches.
Recruited a new CTO and rebuilt the reservation platform, IRIS - showcased with Sabre and featured in Forbes.
After 9/11, and as airlines slashed agent commissions, I re-engineered the economics of every booking: attached travel insurance to every air ticket (raising service fees $10 while lifting close rates from 10% to 12%), steered mix toward higher-commission international bookings with aligned sales incentives, and consolidated the San Diego data center into Tampa.
The board appointed me Interim CEO, COO, and Chairman. I built and ran a competitive strategic-alternatives process and steered the company to a sale that protected its value - with its employees kept on.
17%
sales growth, from flat
+25%
EBITDA before the downturn
5X
growth in product offerings
The result: flat sales became 17% growth, EBITDA rose 25%, product offerings grew 5X - all before the downturn. Then the discipline held through the crisis to a sale to a strategic buyer.
This describes Bob’s roles as CFO and Director, later board-appointed Interim CEO, COO and Chairman of 800 Travel Systems (1999-2002), not a Fractional CFO client engagement. Names, dates, and results are published with permission.
The takeaway: in a hard, low-margin business, the fastest way to grow usually isn’t more volume - it’s re-engineering the economics of what you already do, and running on daily numbers. When the market turned violently, that same discipline landed a safe exit.
Case study 03 · CertiPay · 2017–2023
A $285M PEO: from negative EBITDA to Vensure’s largest acquisition to that point
CFO, recruited by the CEO and largest shareholder
At its core a PEO, ASO, and B2B HR software business moving ~$3.5B of client payroll a year for ~90,000 worksite employees - eight entities, seven locations. The business had outgrown its prior finance leadership: two CFOs departed within two weeks of my arrival, eight sets of books were unreconciled, EBITDA was negative, and the banks and regulators had lost confidence.
What I led
Consolidated two CFO roles into one, reorganized finance by function, recruited five financial managers in about 60 days, and rebuilt the payroll-tax operations team end to end. Reconciled all eight sets of books over 6 to 12 months.
Within 180 days met the bank’s reporting requirements - unlocking a 2X line of credit and positive working capital. Within 120 days earned CertiPay’s first-ever IRS CPEO certification, chased without success for two years prior.
Reset a decade-frozen pricing model with a Power BI driven FP&A capability: 24 months of price protection, then fair-adjustment reviews every 12 months. Annual profit up 50%, attrition under 1%, $5.4M+ in client lifetime value.
New bank-file automation and treasury controls cut funding errors 25%; a platform modernization cut labor costs 17% and delivered first-ever customer-profitability reporting.
Helped carve out and sell the insurance agency to Acentria (Warburg Pincus); when COVID cut revenue 20-30%, raised $2.8M to bridge it with zero layoffs.
11x
EBITDA turnaround, negative to positive
30%
revenue growth over the same period
+50%
annual profit after the pricing reset
The result: an 11x EBITDA turnaround on 30% revenue growth. In 2022 the PEO/ASO/software core sold to Vensure (Stone Point Capital) - the buyer’s largest and most complex acquisition to that point. I stayed on after the close to hand off the integration.
This describes Bob’s role as CFO of CertiPay (2017-2023), not a Fractional CFO client engagement. Names, dates, and results are published with permission.
The takeaway: what earned the outcome was staying long enough to rebuild the confidence of everyone with a stake - employees, clients, banks, regulators, and finally the buyer. That’s what a finance partner who goes the distance with you actually looks like.
Case study 04 · Ace Auto Parts · 1989–1999
A controller who earned the CFO and CTO seats, then led the IPO, seven acquisitions, and a premium exit
Controller, then CFO and CTO
Joined in late 1989 as controller of a wholesale and retail automotive-aftermarket distributor - about 300 delivery trucks, 15 tractor-trailers, a 100,000-square-foot distribution center, nightly deliveries to every store, and roughly 20% of volume flowing back as cores and defects. Real potential, but a substandard financial foundation and too much debt.
What I led
Transformed the financial and inventory foundation: turns to 3.0, fill rates to 98%, lost sales down 10%, markdowns down 50%.
Removed an existential cost: rebuilt loss control and claims management, bringing the workers’ comp experience modifier from 1.2 to 0.8 over about three years - saving millions in annual premiums.
Put every employee on a monthly incentive plan, launched the first store-manager financial training, and led quarterly executive visits to every location - with a roughly 10% sales lift in the month before each visit.
As CTO, led the ERP conversion that became the backbone for integrating acquisitions.
Led the 1996 NASDAQ IPO (~$10M) - de-levering the balance sheet and creating acquisition currency - co-authored the S-1, put an $18M M&A line and $2M vendor PIPE in place, and completed seven acquisitions. Perfect SEC compliance throughout.
$90M
peak sales at 20% EBITDA - 50 locations, 600 employees
7
acquisitions after the 1996 NASDAQ IPO
14%
premium on the sale to Carquest
The result: sales doubled to a $90M peak at 20% EBITDA - 50 locations, 600 employees - and the company sold to Carquest, the second-largest competitor in the country, at a 14% premium in a $30M transaction.
This describes Bob’s roles as Controller, then CFO and CTO of Ace Auto Parts (1989-1999), not a Fractional CFO client engagement. Names, dates, and results are published with permission.
The takeaway: steady and transform the foundation, then make the bigger move. That’s still the order I work in.
Results disclaimer
Past outcomes describe specific businesses, facts, and roles. They do not guarantee that another company will achieve the same result.
Facing a decision like one of these?
Or text me directly at (727) 455-9905.